76-100F Syllabus
Carnegie Mellon University
Summer II 1997
INTRODUCTION
Week One (June 30-July 3)
Monday June 30 Course Overview and administration. Introductions, readings for Wednesday What constitutes a good argument? Wed July 02 Read & Discuss: 'Literacy & Orality in Our Times', Ong. 'Why Write?', Young & Sullivan. Cuneiform extract. Issues: Writing, reading and thought. What relationship does literacy have to thought/consciousness? How important a 'technology of communication' is writing? What is the relationship between writing and 'invention', or the generation of ideas? Rethinking assumptions about writing and language Thursday July 03 Read & Discuss: 'Literacy in 3 Metaphors', Scribner. KGN, Ch. 3 (pp. 32-72) Issues: What is literacy? Definitions. Literacy as individual attribute Literacy as social achievement vs. having an 'essence' Transitions in an argument. Main, Faulty and Return paths. Consider structure of Scribner, Young, Ong, based on concepts in KGN Ch. 3 Friday: Independence Day (No Class)
SUMMARY UNIT
Week Two (July 7-11)
Monday July 07 Do: skim Scribner again Read & Discuss: 'The Social Construction of Race, Class and Gender', Rothenberg. 'What is Social Construction?' (handout, and available on web page). KGN chapter 4 (pp 73-96), 'Milestones'. Issues: Essentialism & social constructionism. What sort of arguments are 'essentialist', and what are 'social constructionist'? Finding examples of each from everyday reasoning. What sort of evidence, counterexamples, counter-arguments are each most vulnerable to? Consider structure of Scribner, and Young & Sullivan based on chapter 4 of KGN. A particular discourse theory: milestones. Wed July 09 Read & Discuss: Handout on 'Assumptions, Implications, & Counterexamples'. Read summary assignment, assignment criteria, and example summary papers. Support, quotation, topic statements, patterns of organization (see web page). KGN Chapter 5. Read & Discuss: Hirsch, 'Literacy and cultural literacy'. Issues: Discovering assumptions, implications, and counterexamples Uses and nature of cultural literacy; literacy, assimilation, enfranchisement In class: Do milestone sketch for Hirsch Thursday July 10 Exchange summary drafts with peer, & do peer review. Friday July 11 Read & Discuss: (Skim) Applebee, Langer, & Mullis, 'Learning to be literate in America'; Gee, 'Literacy, discourse and linguistics' Issues: Functional & discourse approaches to literacy What is literacy? Literacy as social practice In class: Video screening of 'American Tongues' Analyzing the varieties of discourse in the United States Hand in: summary paper.
Week Three (July 14-18)
Monday July 14 Read & Discuss Ogbu, 'Literacy and schooling in subordinate cultures' Kozol, 'Children of the city invincible', and extracts from Will, Suri, Schwebel, Viadero, Heaney. Issues: Literacy, schooling, and society Who is literate? Why? Literacy and debates about Education
ANALYSIS UNIT
Wed July 16 Read & Discuss: KGN Chapters 6 & 7 Synthesis and analysis Establishing common points of discussion Building new knowledge about agreements and disagreements Building a synthesis tree and analysis grid. Read & Discuss: Materials on formal & informal logic, fallacies, critical thinking, revising and composing. Friday July 18 Read & Discuss: Media Literacy Readings, part 1. Harvard Resolutions on Media Literacy; 'Images of Media', Meyrowitz. 'Questioning the Media', Downing & Mohammadi. Read & Discuss: Analysis assignment, criteria and examples; KGN chapter 12. Thinking critically about argument & persuasion continued.
Week Four (July 21-25)
Monday July 21 Media Literacy 2: The issue of Sources & Advertizing. Kirkpatrick's 'Foreword'; Steinem's 'Sex, Lies & Advertising'; Solomon, 'Consider the Sources', FAIR's 'News or Nikes?' Video: 'Signal to Noise'. Tuesday July 22 Exchange analysis drafts with peer, & do peer review.
PARADIGM CASE UNIT
Wed July 23 Read & Discuss: Paradigm case assignment, criteria & examples. KGN chapter 9. Media Literacy 3: 'Hollywood Movies, Society, & Political Criticism' Rothman et. al. Issues: Generating ideas for paradigm cases Narration and argument; Problem cases Hollywood and the Liberal/Conservative Media In class: Discuss possible paradigm cases Hand in: analysis paper Friday July 25 Media Literacy 4: Political Economy of Media Read & Discuss:Herman, 'Media in U.S. Political Economy'; Bagdikian, 'Lords of the Global Village'; Hamelink, 'Information Imbalance'.
Week Five (July 28-August 1)
Monday July 28 Media Literacy 5: Media, Culture and Technology Extracts from McCluhan; Winston, 'How Are Media Born?' Tuesday July 29 Exchange paradigm case drafts with peer, & do peer review. Wed July 30 Media Literacy 6: Activist and Alternative Visions of the Media Read & Discuss: Downing, 'Alternative Media & the Boston Tea Party'. FAIR extract, 'The Importance of Youth Produced Media'. 'The Future of Public TV.' Hand in: paradigm case paper
CONTRIBUTION UNIT
Friday August 01 Media Literacy 7: The Internet & New Information Technologies. Readings, TBA. Read & Discuss: Contribution Assignment, criteria, examples.
Week Six (August 4-7)
Monday August 04 Workshop contribution drafts. Wed August 06 Workshop contribution drafts. Thursday August 07 Final day: summing up course. Hand in: Contribution papers.